Click the read the latest about this in the Columbia StateImagine you picked up the newspaper and saw that in some little country in the developing world, in the middle of an election campaign, 180 candidates were thrown off the ballot for a ‘legal technicality’ and none of them were incumbent office holders.

“Typical banana republic” you would say; and you would be right.

Welcome to the banana republic we call home – South Carolina.

The last couple of weeks has seen 180 Democratic and Republican candidates thrown off the ballot for the June primaries. These were candidates for state House and Senate and many local offices.

Not one of the 180 was an incumbent state House or Senate member – none.

How did this start and who is responsible? Much we don’t know for sure; a lot less than we do know for sure. But one thing is sure – it’s another example of the corrupt system of politics as usual in our beloved Palmetto State.

There is a lot of talk about who is responsible for this whole thing blowing up. There are plenty of folks who think it was a couple of so-called leaders, one Democrat and one Republican, who worked together to light the fuse. Allegedly, one was trying to protect the other from a primary challenge and neither realized, or perhaps didn’t care, that the end result would be 180 other causalities.

Once this all exploded, there was a lot of back and forth about court actions, a few editorials and some members of the legislature said they thought it ‘ought to be fixed’. But despite this sound and furry, as of now, nothing has changed. The end result is the same – 180 candidates off the ballot and no incumbent House or Senate members endangered.

Back in the 1990’s, one of my companies, along with many others, did a lot of work with civic organizations, political parties and candidates in the Eastern European countries emerging from years of communist oppression. Our work was to help these folks build and support democratic institutions and processes, and most importantly to try and foster a long-term faith in the ideas and operations of democracy.

One journalist dubbed us as a ‘Peace Corps for democracy.’ We weren’t paid much, sometimes nothing at all, and often we spent our own money – but we were very proud of the work we did. I still am.

In most any of these countries,  there would have been rioting in the streets if, all of a sudden, 180 non-incumbents had been thrown off the ballot on a legal technicality.  All sides would have cried fraud and condemned this type of ‘banana republic politics.’ Groups like the Carter Center and other international election monitoring groups would have denounced it for what it is – corruption.

What makes this latest political melt down in our state so bad, is that it’s just the latest and most visible in a long series of examples of political corruption and the good-old-boy system at work in our state.

Now You See It, Now You Don’t’ Ethics Flip Flop – Earlier this month, Gov. Haley was charged with ethics violations and brought before the House Ethics Committee. First, the Committee unanimously agreed  that the allegations were sufficiently serious that they should be investigated. Then,(and after alleged Haley threats of retaliation by exposing problems of the members of the Committee) they reversed themselves and voted 5-1 along party lines to dismiss the charges.

Howard Rich, Carpetbaggers and Scalawags – Howard Rich, the wealthy real-estate mogul and radical ideologue from New York, has organized his buddies to dump millions of dollars in campaign money and contributions to ‘buy’ members of the legislature to support his dangerous experiment in private school vouchers. And worst of all, he finds dozens of willing Republicans (and a few Democrats) to take his money and use our children like lab rats in his radical social-engineering experiment.

Pay-to-Play Tax Reform – Our state is bleeding money because of the loss of over $3 billion a year in sales tax exemptions. Most all of these are the result of the ‘corrupt triangle’ among special interest groups and lobbyists, campaign contributions and legislators. Even the Republican leadership’s own study said we should eliminate $1 billion in exemptions. Then, the predators went to work and this $1 billion shrank to $220 million and finally when it was passed into law a few weeks ago, it was only $11 million.

Ethics Laws That Aren’t – Our state’s ethics laws for elected officials are so lax as to be essentially non-existent. An elected official or their company could be getting hundreds of thousands, even millions, of dollars in business from state and local governments that they influence, and it could all remain secret. In fact, it happens every day.

The list goes on and on and you could fill a whole newspaper with just these issues of ethics and corruption, but you get the point.

The real tragedy in all this is the reaction, or lack or reaction, of the people in our state to this corruption. Generally, they just shake their head, shrug their shoulders and say, ‘its corrupt politics as usual – there’s nothing I can do’.

This attitude is precisely the biggest issue we battled as the Peace Corps for democracy in these ‘backward’ countries.’ People didn’t have faith that the democratic system would work and things could change.

Perhaps we should change our state symbol from the palmetto tree to the banana tree – it sometimes seems there is not that much difference.

Editor's note: This story originally published at Photo: Created for from a photo licensed on
Phil Noble

Phil Noble

Phil Noble is a businessman from Charleston and he currently serves as President of the South Carolina New Democrats, an independent reform group started by former Gov. Richard Riley. Noble is one of the leading experts in the US and internationally on the Internet and politics. Noble is the founder of PoliticsOnline and its affiliated company Phil Noble & Associates, an international public affairs consulting firm. Noble is a veteran of over 300 political campaigns and public affairs projects in 40 states and 30 countries. He has worked to elect the head of state in 15 countries.

  1. Looks like Hussein in the banana republic of Illinois eliminated competitors before he spent his career voting “present.” Quoth CNN:
    “As a community organizer, he had helped register thousands of voters. But
    when it came time to run for office, he employed Chicago rules to invalidate the
    voting petition signatures of three of his challengers.”
    However “corrupt” you want to make Southern states out to be — they’re nothing compared to Progressive Democrat strongholds like New York, New Jersey and Illinois.

      1. How is this “hijacking”? The author’s point is that “there would have been rioting in the streets if, all of a sudden, 180
        non-incumbents had been thrown off the ballot on a legal technicality.:All sides would have cried fraud and condemned this type of ‘banana
        republic politics.’ Groups like the Carter Center and other
        international election monitoring groups would have denounced it for
        what it is – corruption.”

        Well friends: this are exactly the sort of methods Barack Obama used to begin his political career in the Democrat party.

        1. The subject is the South Carolina situation – not something in Illinois. I get the last word on this. You are welcome to write to me off line, but not here.

Comments are closed.