Follow us: Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Google+ Follow us on Linkedin Follow us on Tumblr Subscribe to our RSS or Atom feed
Monday, November 20, 2017
Southern Weather Radar


Our Writers

  • Adam Peck
  • Alan Gordon
  • Alex Kearns
  • Alex Seitz-Wald
  • Alice Murray
  • Allison Korn
  • Alyssa Cagle
  • Amanda Marcotte
  • Amanda Peterson Beadle
  • Andrea Grimes
  • Andrea Lee Meyer
  • Andrew Bowen
  • Andy Brack
  • Andy Kopsa
  • Andy Miller
  • Andy Schmookler
  • Ann Marie Pace
  • Ann Woolner & Leonard Ray Teel
  • Anna Dolianitis
  • Anna Forbes and Kate Ryan
  • Annelise Thim
  • Anoni Muss
  • April Adams
  • April Moore
  • Ariel Harris
  • Armando
  • Arthur Blaustein
  • Austen Risolvato
  • Austin McMurria
  • Barry Hollander
  • Bert Roughton III
  • Beth Ostlund
  • Betsey Dahlberg
  • Bill Caton
  • Bill Hamm
  • Bill Mankin
  • Bill Montgomery
  • Bill Moyers & Michael Winship
  • Bill Phillips
  • Bill Semple
  • Bill Tush
  • Billy Howard
  • Bob Bohanan
  • Bob Pritchard
  • Booth Malone
  • Bootsie Lucas
  • Boyd Lewis
  • Brad Clayton
  • Braden Goyette For ProPublica
  • Brandon Collins
  • Brett Martin
  • Brian Randall
  • Brianna Peterson
  • Bruce Dixon
  • Bruce E. Levine
  • Burton Cox
  • Candice Dyer
  • Carl Kline
  • Carol Carter
  • Carson M. Lamb
  • Casey Hayden
  • Cathleen Hulbert
  • Center for American Progress
  • Chantille Cook
  • Charles Finn
  • Charles O. Hendrix Jr.
  • Charles Seabrook
  • Charles Walston
  • Chelsea Toledo
  • Chelsey Willis
  • Chris Bowers
  • Chris Kromm
  • Chris Wohlwend
  • Christopher Burdette
  • Chrys B. Graham
  • Chuck Collins
  • Cliff Green
  • Cody Maxwell
  • Collin Kelley
  • Craig Miller
  • Crissinda Ponder
  • Dallas Lee
  • Dan Kennedy
  • Daniel Flynn
  • Daniel K. Williams
  • Daniel Palmer
  • Danny Fulks
  • Dante Atkins
  • Darby Britto
  • Dave Cooley
  • Dave Johnson
  • Dave Pruett
  • David Bradford
  • David Evans
  • David Harris-Gershon
  • David Jenks
  • David Kyler
  • David Parker
  • David Roberts
  • David Rotenstein
  • David Swanson
  • Dean Baker
  • Deb Barshafsky
  • Debbie Houston
  • Deborah Chasteen
  • Denise Oliver Velez
  • Dennis McCarthy
  • Desiree Evans
  • Dian Cai
  • Diana
  • Diane Rooks
  • Dina Rasor
  • Dindy Yokel
  • Doc
  • Don Lively
  • Don O'Briant
  • Donnie Register
  • Door Guy
  • Doug Couch
  • Doug Cumming
  • Dr. Brian Moench
  • Dr. Dorothy Ann Boyd-Bragg
  • Dr. Nick De Bonis
  • Dr. Ravi Batra
  • E. David Ferriman
  • Earl Fisher
  • Eden Landow
  • Eileen Dight
  • Eleanor Ringel Cater
  • Elizabeth Shugg
  • Ellen Brown
  • Elliott Brack
  • Erin Kotecki Vest
  • Fatima Najiy
  • FishOutofWater
  • Francisco Silva
  • Frank Povah
  • Fred Brown
  • Frederick Palmer
  • Gadi Dechter, Michael Ettlinger
  • Gail Kiracofe
  • Gaius
  • Georgia Logothetis
  • Gib Ennis
  • Gina Williams
  • Gita M. Smith
  • Glenn Carroll
  • Glenn Overman
  • Gordon Anderson
  • Gregory C. Dixon
  • Gryphon Corpus
  • Hamp Skelton
  • Harriet Barr
  • Heather Boushey
  • Henry Dreyer
  • Henry Foresman
  • Hollis B. Ball III
  • Hugh
  • Hyde Post
  • Ian Kim
  • Ian Millhiser
  • Isabel Owen
  • Ivy Brashear
  • J.A. Myerson
  • Jack deJarnette
  • Jack Wilkinson
  • Jacklyn C. Citero
  • Jake Olzen
  • James Hataway
  • James Marc Leas
  • James N. Maples
  • Janet Ward
  • Jasmine Burnett
  • Jason Palmer
  • Jason Parker
  • Jay Thompson
  • Jaz Brisack
  • Jeff Cochran
  • Jeff Davis
  • Jeff Rayno
  • Jeff Spross
  • Jeffry Scott
  • Jennifer Hill
  • Jesse Harwell
  • Jessica Luton
  • Jim Allen
  • Jim Bentley and Jeff Nesmith
  • Jim Clark
  • Jim Cobb
  • Jim Fitzgerald
  • Jim Newell
  • Jim Stovall
  • Jim Walls
  • Jim Warren
  • Jimmy Booth
  • Jing Luo
  • Jingle Davis
  • JL Strickland
  • Joan Donovan
  • Jodi Jacobson
  • Jody Wegmueller
  • Joe Earle
  • Joe Shifalo
  • Joel Groover
  • Joey Ledford
  • John A. Tures
  • John Dembowski
  • John Hickman
  • John Hickman with Sarah Bartlett
  • John Huie
  • John M. Williams
  • John Manasso
  • John Sugg
  • John Tabellione
  • John Yow
  • Jon Sinton
  • Jonathan Grant
  • Jonathan Odell
  • Joni Hunnicutt
  • Jonna Pattillo
  • Joseph B. Atkins
  • Joseph Gatins
  • Josh Dorner
  • Josh Sewell
  • Joy Moses
  • Judith Stough
  • Judy McCarthy
  • Juli Ward
  • Julian Bond
  • Julian Riggs Smith
  • Julianne Wyrick
  • Julie Ajinkya
  • Julie Puckett Fodera
  • Just Plain Will
  • Kaili Joy Gray
  • Kate Greer
  • Kate McNally
  • Katherine A. Edmonds
  • Kathleen Brewin Lewis
  • Kathleen Harbin
  • Kathleen R. Gegan
  • Kathryn Hoffman
  • KC Wildmoon
  • Keith Graham
  • Ken Edelstein
  • Ken Haldin
  • Ken Hawkins
  • Ken Peacock
  • Kevin Austin
  • Kevin Duffy
  • Kip Burke
  • Kirk McAlpin
  • Kirsten Barr
  • Kos Moulitsas
  • Kristie Macrakis
  • Lacey Avery
  • Lamont Cranston
  • Laura Clawson
  • Laura Smith
  • Laurence Lewis
  • Lawrence S. Wittner
  • Lee Leslie
  • Lee Robin
  • Leon Galis
  • Leonce Gaiter
  • Les Eatwell
  • LikeTheDew
  • Linda Hunt Beckman
  • Linda Jordan Tucker
  • Lisa Byerley Gary
  • Lisa Kerr
  • Lois Beckett, Propublica
  • Lorraine Berry
  • Louie Crew Clay
  • Louis Mayeux
  • Lovell Jones, Ph.D.
  • Lucy Emerson Sullivan
  • Lucy Guest
  • Maggie Lee
  • Maisha White
  • Mandy Richburg Rivers
  • Margi Ness
  • Marian Wang, ProPublica
  • Marie Diamond
  • Mark Dohle
  • Mark Johnson
  • Mark Sumner
  • Martha W. Fagan
  • Mary Civille
  • Mary Elizabeth King
  • Mary Kay Andrews
  • Mary Lee
  • Mary Willis Cantrell
  • Matt Blakely
  • Matt Johnson
  • Matt Musick
  • Matt Renner
  • Matthew Wright
  • Maurice Carter
  • Meg Livergood Gerrish
  • Meghan Miller
  • Melanie Rochat
  • Melinda Ennis
  • Michael Bailey
  • Michael Beckel
  • Michael Castengera
  • Michael Ettlinger
  • Michael J. Solender
  • Michael Linden
  • Michael Lux
  • Michael W. Twitty
  • Mike ”Hunter” Lazzaro
  • Mike Copeland
  • Mike Cox
  • Mike Handley
  • Mike Lofgren
  • Mike Ludwig
  • Mike Williams
  • Mimi Skelton
  • Moni Basu
  • Monica Smith
  • Murray Browne
  • Myra Blackmon
  • Nancy Melton
  • Nancy Puckett
  • Nancy Robinson
  • Nancy Rogers
  • Neill Herring
  • Nelly McDaid
  • Nikki Gardner
  • Niles Reddick
  • Noel Holston
  • Occupy Wall Street
  • Overman & Senn
  • Pamela Sumners
  • Pat Garofalo
  • Pat LaMarche
  • Pat Norman
  • Patrick Andendall
  • Patrick L. Ledford
  • Patsy Dickey
  • Patti Ghezzi
  • Paul Buchheit
  • Paul Krupin
  • Paul Rutledge
  • Paul Thim
  • Pete & Jack
  • Peter Crawford
  • Peter Turnbull
  • Phil Gast
  • Phil Noble
  • Philip Graitcer
  • Phyllis Alesia Perry
  • Phyllis Gilbert
  • Piney Woods Pete
  • Polly
  • R S
  • R.L. Miller
  • Rafael Alvarez
  • Randy Conway
  • Randy Schiltz
  • Ray Bearfield
  • Raymond L. Atkins
  • Reagan Walker
  • Rebecca Sive
  • Ric Latarski
  • Richard Eisel
  • Righton C. Willis
  • Rob Chambers
  • Rob Coppock
  • Rob Douthit
  • Robert Allen
  • Robert Dardenne
  • Robert E Hunt Jr
  • Robert Jensen
  • Robert Lamb
  • Robert M. Williams, Jr.
  • Robert Mashburn
  • Robert Weiner & Richard Mann
  • Robin Marty
  • Rodney Adams
  • Roger Gregory
  • Ron Feinberg
  • Ron Taylor
  • Rose Aguilar
  • Rose Weaver
  • Rosemary Griggs
  • Russ Wellen
  • Sam Morton
  • Sao Magnifico
  • Sara Amis
  • Sarah Ayres
  • Sarah Bufkin
  • Saralyn Chesnut
  • Scott Anna
  • Scott Borchert
  • Scott Keyes
  • Scott Wooledge
  • Sean Manion
  • Seth Cline
  • Shane Gilreath
  • Sharon M. Riley
  • Shay Dawkins
  • Sheffield Hale
  • Sheila Barnard Nungesser
  • Sigrid Sanders
  • SoniaTai
  • Sonya Collins
  • Soraya Chemaly
  • Spencer Lawton
  • Stephanie Taylor
  • Stephen Lacey
  • Stephen Wingeier
  • Steve King
  • Steve Krodman
  • Steve Valk
  • Stuart Liss
  • Sue Sturgis
  • Sujigu
  • Susan De Bonis
  • Susan Soper
  • Susan Wilson
  • Suz Korbel
  • Tammy Andrews
  • Tammy Ingram
  • Tanya Somanader
  • Ted Kooser
  • Terri Evans
  • The Barnacle Goose
  • Thomas A. Bledsoe
  • Tiger Liliuokalani
  • Tim Oliver
  • Timothy Freeman
  • Timothy Hurst
  • Tom Baxter
  • Tom Crawford
  • Tom Ferguson
  • Tom Millsop
  • Tom Poland
  • Tom Walker
  • Travis Waldron
  • Travis Waldron & Pat Garofalo
  • Trevor Stone Irvin
  • Tricia Collins
  • Troubadour
  • Valerie Evans
  • Viveca Novak
  • Waldron, Somanader & Garofalo
  • Walter Rhett
  • Wanda Argersinger
  • Wayne Countryman
  • Wayne Johnson
  • We The People
  • Will Cantrell
  • Will Nelson
  • William Cotter
  • William Hedgepeth
  • Yana Kunichoff
  • Yasmin Vafa
  • Zack Beauchamp
  • Zack Ford
  • Zaid Jilani
  • Zaina Budayr




  • Writer Login


    Farting Through the Fence

    A History Lesson: How “Southern Values” Ruined America

    by | 4 | Jul 16, 2012

    Having spent the last forty years trying to get college students to think about the past in ways that will equip them better to think about what they see in the present, I clearly see the benefits of such an approach. However, just as I sort of jumped ugly with the Tea Baggers behind this attempt to rewrite U. S. history for Georgia public school students recently, I have no more patience with high-minded lefties who are not only willing but in this case clearly eager to distort or oversimplify the past in order to support their own ideological take on what’s happening today. Sara Robinson shows no hesitation or nuance whatsoever in blaming the revival of “conservative Southern values” for the fact that we are now at the mercy of what she sees as “a brutal strain of American aristocrats.” This attempt to use a facile, overgeneralized, and conveniently self-serving account of the South’s history and its role within American history to explain everything she feels is wrong in the country today has garnered plaudits all over the left-hand side of the blogosphere (“Best description of the Southern mind and its priorities that I have ever read. Ever. Anywhere.”) Seeing this simply affirms for me how desperately some Yankee liberals need to convince both themselves and the rest of us of their intellectual and moral superiority.

    "United Stereotypes of America" by Haley Nahman

    “United Stereotypes of America” by Haley Nahman

    Perish the thought that the country has shifted sharply to the right over the last two generations because they failed to lead or grew smug and aloof and lost touch with the people. Rather, it’s simply that many of those who once stood ready to follow them all the way to Armageddon, if need be, suddenly fell prey to a contagion of reaction and intolerance that, after festering for nearly four centuries, suddenly erupted across the Mason-Dixon line and quickly infected the rest of country. Forget that it has been pervasive nationally for several decades now. For the people writing this script, this pestilential scourge of hide-bound conservatism, evangelical Protestantism and ardent anti-intellectualism remains,not only in its origins but in its essence, peculiarly and indelibly southern. As Sara Robinson puts it, “from its origins in the fever swamps of the lowland South, the worldview of the old Southern aristocracy can now be found nationwide. Buttressed by the arguments of Ayn Rand [a native of St. Petersburg, after all, albeit the one in Russia] who updated the ancient slaveholder ethic for the modern age—it has been exported to every corner of the culture.”

    Ms. Robinson is not by any means the first pundit to blame the nation’s rightward tilt over the last two generations on the proliferation of “southern” values, which in her view and that of her cohort ain’t changed one damn bit since Jamestown. According to Robinson, before this plague of Dixie-itis enveloped the country, we had been benignly “dominated by a New England-based Yankee aristocracy that was rooted in Puritan communitarian values, educated at the Ivies and marinated in an ethic of noblesse oblige (the conviction that those who possess wealth and power are morally bound to use it for the betterment of society).” Contrast this, she argues, to “the plantation aristocracy of the lowland South, which has been notable throughout its four-hundred-year history for its utter lack of civic interest, its hostility to the very ideas of democracy and human rights, its love of hierarchy, its fear of technology and progress, its reliance on brutality and violence to maintain ‘order,’ and its outright celebration of inequality as an order divinely ordained by God.”

    The roots of this deplorable mindset, Robinson airily explains, may be found in the fact that “the elites of the deep South are descended mainly from the owners of sugar, rum and cotton plantations of Barbados” who, after screwing up the Caribbean island beyond repair, proceeded to descend en masse upon the coastal lowlands of the Deep South where they managed not only to recreate the Barbadian horrors of brutality, greed, and ruthless exploitation of slave labor but to impose the controlling ethos behind them on an entire region, apparently in perpetuity. In support of this rather sweeping contention, Robinson cites the work of one Colin Woodward, who, so far as I can tell, read something somewhere about several hundred planters from Barbados emigrating to South Carolina and decided to run with it.

    At any rate, Robinson apparently was so smitten with Woodward’s Barbadian thesis that she decided to take it for a little test drive herself, all the way to “the gleaming new cities of the South and West.” In the years after World War II, the latter drew “a vast number” of their new residents “out of the South,” meaning that “the elites that rose along with these cities tended to hew to the old Southern code, and either tacitly or openly resist the moral imperatives of the Yankee canon.” Thus along with Dallas, Houston, and Atlanta, “the soaring postwar fortunes of cities like Los Angeles, Las Vegas, [and] Phoenix” [Everybody has noticed the predominance of southern accents in Vegas, right?] quickly fed that ancient Barbadian slaveholder model of power with plenty of room and resources to launch a fresh and unexpected twentieth-century revival.”

    Robinson, who seems never to have met a sweeping negative generalization about the South that she didn’t like, also apparently never encountered Abe Lincoln’s reported observation that “you can’t fertilize a field by farting through the fence,” to which, in this case, with characteristic indelicacy, I would add, “especially when you have clearly been feasting on a steady diet of unsubstantiated generalizations, stereotypes, and downright inaccurate assertions of fact.“ By way of a few of many examples, how about: “Since shortly after the Revolution, the Yankee elites have worked hard to keep the upper hand on America’s culture, economy and politics—and much of our success as a nation rests on their success at keeping plantation culture sequestered in the South, and its scions largely away from the levers of power.” [So much for my distinct recollection that nine of the first twelve presidents of the United States and three of the first six chief justices of the Supreme Court were actually from slaveholding states.]

    There’s also: “The Yankees thought that government’s job was to better the lot of the lower classes.” [Yep. This was an especially passionate conviction for ol’ Bill McKinley and Cal Coolidge, all right.]

    And this: “They countered Yankee hegemony by building their own universities, grooming their own leaders and creating their own media.” [The absence or weakness of which had made them the butt of Yankee derision for more than a century.] “By the 1990s, they were staging the RINO hunts that drove the last Republican moderates (almost all of them Yankees, by either geography or cultural background) and the meritocratic order they represented to total extinction within the GOP.” [Apparently, I missed all the reports of southerners cramming into buses and heading north to vote these wussies out.] “A decade later, the Tea Party became the voice of the unleashed id of the old Southern order, bringing it forward into the twenty-first century with its full measure of selfishness, racism, superstition, and brutality intact.” [Look, no one with a lick of history in his/her head would argue that the South hasn’t left a disproportionate share of smudges on the national character or that it hasn’t produced more than its share of what Lewis Grizzard called the kind of folks who “think the moonshot’s fake and wrestlin’s real,” but give it a rest, will you?]

    And, finally, this: “As [Michael] Lind points out, to the horror of his Yankee father, George W. Bush proceeded to run the country exactly like Woodard’s description of a Barbadian slavelord.” [So, let me get this straight, wasn’t this horrified Ivy-educated “Yankee father” and scion of a distinguished Connecticut family the same guy who played to white racial fears nationwide by shamelessly flogging the Willie Horton episode in 1988? As to his son, didn’t he attend prep school in New England and wind up with degrees from both Yale and Harvard?] “And Barack Obama has done almost nothing to roll this victory back.” [According to Robinson’s historical approach, this proves conclusively that Obama was actually born in Barbados. And to think that I didn’t even know they allowed Muslims there!]

    ###
    Jim Cobb

    Jim Cobb

    Jim Cobb teaches history at the University of Georgia, where he is B. Phinizy Spalding Distinguished Professor in the History of the American South. His most recent book is the South and America Since World War II (Oxford University Press, 2010) He has been known to blog at www.cobbloviate.com.

     

    Print Friendly, PDF & Email

     

    • hannah

      I’m not sure why geography is supposed to be such a culturally defining entity. I suspect it may be related to ambient temperatures which prompt humans to migrate to find their comfort zone. In flat terrain, that involves moving north or south, depending on how heat tolerant a person is. In mountainous regions, the migration can be vertical and seasonal to accomplish the same end. People whose awareness of their environment is slim to non-existent, either stay put or wander around at random. The latter behavior is very annoying to people who want to keep track of them. Making them carry ID cards is supposed to make it easier.

    • Willbkeller

      Who’s Sara Robinson? No context. Could not find her on Google.

      • Jeff Cochran

        She wrote the story Jim refers to. Press the “this case” link in the first paragraph and you can read her story which ran in Salon. Jim did a great job in providing context.

    • Jim -- just thinking about how much I miss reading your stories (I have quoted this one many times). Of course, I googled you and realized I could have been reading your stories these last few years at http://cobbloviate.com/ (let me know if you would like us to also post any of your stories on the dew.
      I hope you are well and happy. -- Lee

  • Worthy of Comment






  • Health Care: U.S. vs. Canada



  • 'L-G-B-T' - James Corden
    Sings for Transgender Troops



  • "The Elections Are Rigged" Arnold Schwarzenegger On Trump, Congress, Gerrymandering

     

  •  
     
     
  • %d bloggers like this: