- Important: All passwords were reset on 06/15/11. Old passwords will no longer work. Click here to retrieve your password.
- Subscribe to Our Free Dewsletter
We are non-commercial, all volunteer and supported by our readers. Please help sustain the Dew by making a donation.
Liberty of the Powerless
The Cause of Freedom
Scarcely two years have passed since excited crowds of Tea Party activists thundered fervent evocations of individual liberty and yet today there is only a faint echo of their temper tantrum. Although they could be faulted for puerile conceptions of the American Revolution, for treating the U.S. Constitution as holy text rather than as a deal struck about the rules of the game for competing for power in a liberal democracy, and for barely concealed racist hysteria about President Barack Obama, we can still grant that some Tea Party activists were sincere in declaring their love of freedom. That is what makes their nearly complete silence in the face of current threats to individual liberty from state governments across the country worth noting.
Today Republican controlled state governments from Virginia to Arizona are on the offensive against unionized workers, Black voters, animal rights and anti-capitalist activists, undocumented workers and students, unemployed and welfare recipients, and women seeking birth control and abortion services. Among the recent punitive measures are universal drug testing for public employees in Florida and unemployment insurance recipients in Arizona, the criminalization of investigations of animal cruelty on farms in Iowa and the publication of a hit-list of abortion providers in Tennessee. America has not witnessed such an embrace of coercion at the state level against this many groups since the passage of anti-syndicalist laws of the 1920s. With the exception of an ineffectual and irrelevant squeak from the Georgia Tea Party about an anti-picketing law, nothing has been heard in opposition from the thousands of self-proclaimed patriots who had postured as defenders of freedom.
That many of the Tea Party activists have been engrossed in the spectacle of the Republican Party primary campaigns explains some of the silence. That the targets for the coercive power of government simply do not resemble the white, middle income, middle aged male demographic of the Tea Party explains more. However something decidedly uglier is also at work. Mass movements on the Right are often less about bread and butter public policy issues than about social status anxiety. We know that Ku Klux Klan membership in America exploded in the 1920s because of white anxiety about erosion in the racial hierarchy in the South and Midwest, that European fascism was born in Italy in the same decade in response to class anxiety of the middle class desperate not to fall into the working class, and that the Islamists who seized power in Iran in 1979 were often traditional religious, merchant and landowning elites envious of the modern business and professional elites who prospered under the Shah of Iran. Whatever the specific ideological claims deployed, perceived loss of social status is a powerful impetus for political mobilization.
So if America has not heard from the Tea Party activists of late it may be because Republican governors and state legislatures have been busy reinforcing their privileged status. The new regulations for documents proving identity, drug tests or mandatory “volunteer” work in return for employment or benefits, restrictions on freedom of the press and assembly, and threatening or humiliating abortion laws impose no constraints on their freedoms but more importantly symbolize their privileged status as members of the population less subject to the coercive authority of the state. The raft of new laws limiting the liberty of the powerless or disempowered is the payoff from Republican state lawmakers for histrionic posturing that briefly captured the attention of journalists. That it stands in contradiction to Tea Party rhetoric about liberty is evidence for the proposition that that social status anxiety trumps abstract ideals.
If there is an upside to all this it is that Republicans have handed ownership of individual liberty as rhetoric and issues back to the ideological Left. As has been true so often in the history of the United States, the cause of freedom once again belongs to those capable of looking not only after their own interests but beyond to the interests of others who are also oppressed.
Worthy of Comment
Also on the Dew
I had an interesting morning yesterday at the Free Clinic. Once a week I’m a Spanish interpreter in an organization supported by over 400 volunteers who give a few hours a week of their particular expertise in a smoothly run team. We cater for patients with chronic conditions needing regular medication, having no access to health insurance. Yesterday we met a new patient who is deaf and mute since birth. We took her through her eligibility interview with a social worker, then a nurse took her health history, followed by a doctor's consultation and a laboratory test. In the seven years I Read on →
My beloved colleagues in Teh Media sure get on my last damn nerve. Most of the time it's just from sloppy work or jumping on whatever bandwagon is rolling by at the time, something along the lines of a pet peeve. Like when my Twitter list of political reporters blows up with some hashtag meme instead of actual reporting. Today it's #Obamacareinthreewords, launched by that icon of credibility, Rep. Darrell Issa. It's the second time around for that one -- Rep. Kevin McCarthy launched it the first time last June. (@WhiteHouse even got in on it, tweeting "It's.The.Law." Republicans responded with "arrogance Read on →
For some reason, a letter from the lobbying arm of the Heritage Foundation was characterized as having been received by NBC News, as if it were some sort of privileged communication. In fact, the thing was a press release and rather obviously designed to change the conversation about the Heritage Foundation from trying to defend the indefensible "study" of Hispanic intellectual insufficiency to food stamps, a real two-fer issue. Two-fer in the sense of being offensive on two fronts since the dollars doled out represent a subsidy to industrial agriculture, even as they serve to remind the indigent that, if they're Read on →
We are barbarians. I can't take credit for saying that, although I completely agree. My friend did that, just after I posted this video on my Facebook page: I was all set to write about how Charles Ramsey isn't a hero. But this, this makes me realize that I was wrong about that. Here I was thinking Ramsey, the guy who answered Amanda Berry's cries for help, ending the imprisonment of three women in Cleveland, shouldn't be called a hero because he just did the right thing. My argument was that we've set the bar way too low for bestowing hero Read on →