Follow us: Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Google+ Follow us on Linkedin Follow us on Vodpod Follow us on Tumblr Subscribe to our RSS or Atom feed
Thursday, May 17, 2012

Political DewTubes

Click to view more DewTubes – fresh most days
Watch videos at Vodpod and more of my videos




When Muslim Garb Makes You Nervous

by | 7, Add your Comment | Oct 21, 2010

Islam-o-phobia in America got ratcheted up several degrees today when NPR fired veteran journalist and commentator, Juan Williams, for stating on FOX news that he “gets nervous when he sees people in Muslim garb on an airplane.”

Williams made his comments on the O’Rielly Factor Monday where the uber-conservative host had invited several guests to discuss his own appearance last week on ABC’s “The View” during which Joy Behar and Whoopi Goldberg walked off the set in protest of O’Reilly’s views on Muslims.

When learned and well respected reporters with pedigrees of scholarly writing and journalistic excellence in coverage of American civil rights state on national television that they get “worried” and anxious in seeing airline passengers who identify themselves through their clothing as Muslim, every one of us has cause for concern.  Should we fear equally large and burly black men (Williams is black) that we encounter on darkened city streets? What about Aryan skinhead types with tattoos, they must certainly pose a threat. And Jewish accountants, they’re likely to rob us with their pencils.

Where does the stereotyping and ingrained categorization end?

The paranoia that is rampant in the American psyche cuts at the very tolerance and religious freedom principles this country is built upon. The widening polarization occurring across our land between those that “look” and “act” like Americans and everyone else, is creating a homogenized “just-like-us” urban ghetto-ization that makes for less diverse, less enriching and ultimately, less fulfilling neighborhoods and communities.

We shouldn’t be angry that Williams feels this way or even that he expressed those feelings. We should be concerned and angry at the “why” behind Williams’ feelings, a much bigger issue that deserves exploring.

That’s not going to happen however. There is way too much positioning and posturing to be had.

From the right: “All Juan Williams did is say both exactly how he feels and how many, many other Americans feel on this subject,” wrote Erick Erickson on his “Red State” blog. “The man’s body of work makes clear he is no bigot. But we sure can’t offend Muslims can we?”

From the left: “NPR should address the fact that one of its news analysts seems to believe that all airline passengers who are perceived to be Muslim can legitimately be viewed as security threats,” Council on American-Islamic Relations National Executive Director Nihad Awad was quoted as saying.

You haven’t heard the last of this. The talking heads will be talking (likely shouting) AT each other for weeks to come. Therein lies the problem.

What happened to dialogue in this country? You know, the type of discourse where people actually listen and consider other perspectives.

Perhaps that is what people are really afraid of.

###
Michael J. Solender

About Michael J. Solender

Michael J. Solender is a recent corporate refugee whose opinion and satire has been featured in The Richmond Times Dispatch, The Winston-Salem Journal, and Richmond Style Weekly. He writes a weekly Neighborhoods column for The Charlotte Observer and is the City Life Editor for Charlotte ViewPoint. His micro-fiction has been featured online at Bull Men’s Fiction, Calliope Nerve, Danse Macabre, Dogzplot, Gloom Cupboard, Full of Crow, Pangur Ban Party and others.

You can find more of his work at his website and also at his blog.

 

Print Friendly

 

  • Vincent Allen

    You have eloquently captured the most serious concern that I have for our country, along with the private sector censorship that results in somebody getting fired for simply stating how they feel, personally, about a particular subject. The crazy trend of “shooting the messenger” is just as dangerous as the specific issue being discussed, which goes to your point about how we now spend so much time shouting at each other and not listening.

    • http://hannah.smith-family.com/ Monica Smith

      Call me unfeeling, but how a reporter or journalist “feels” is really irrelevant. People who address the public should be able to not only think before they speak, but to control how they feel.
      I will freely admit there was a time when being a solitary female on an elevator with an unfamiliar male made me feel uneasy. It never occurred to me to allow myself to be intimidated by what was obviously an irrational fear.
      Appearances are deceiving. It would be good if more people remembered that.

  • http://cheeseaisle.blogspot.com Steve Krodman

    “‘NPR should address the fact that one of its news analysts seems to believe that all airline passengers who are perceived to be Muslim can legitimately be viewed as security threats,’ Council on American-Islamic Relations National Executive Director Nihad Awad was quoted as saying.”

    Putting aside the (considerable) baggage CAIR brings to this discussion, let’s step back and look at Mr. Williams’s concern from an apolitical standpoint, shall we?

    When you consider the 9/11 attacks, the failed shoe- and BVD-bombers, as well as a goodly percentage of other air-related terror incidents, it ain’t blue-haired grannies from Pasadena involved. It also is not the Amish, Orthodox Jews, or people wearing rainbow clown wigs. If it were the Amish who had perpetrated the 9/11 attacks, I can tell you right now that I’d be sweating bullets every time I got on a plane with a dude wearing a black suit, a broad-brimmed hat, and an Abe Lincoln beard. Do I have to state the obvious?

    This is not to say that all Muslims (or even a sizable percentage of them) are air terrorists -- that’s ridiculous. But given the fact that, in recent years, a statistically significant percentage of air terrorists have been Muslims, you have to be irrational not to have some level of concern, even if you -- like most people -- choose to decide that it’s not an actionable level of concern.

    Me, I’m not so much worried about the guy wearing the thobe in the row behind me. I (and Vincent Allen, too, if I understand his comment correctly) am much more worried about today’s über-politically correct environment where people’s personal opinions, if expressed, put them at risk of their livelihoods… and where other people are all too quick to throw someone under the bus without considering the fine points of history, facts, and context.

  • Jeanette Cheezum

    Excellent article, Michael.

  • Mark Dohle

    Very well done. However I think NPR made a serious blunder in firing Juan Williams. It was only after all his personal opinion, we all have them, we don’t have to agree.

  • http://www.littlewallaby.com Frank Povah

    Surely it is the job of a journalist to report, not comment. Comment is supposed to be the domain of the leader writers, not those who cover the stories, which seems to be at the crux of the matter.

    While personally not agreeing with him getting the chop – discipline would have been a more appropriate course, but then it’s not the done thing anymore to discipline a celebrity is it – I think a lot of the stink has arisen because he dared air his views on public radio. It gives both sides more than ample opportunity to express angst and hang out the holier than thou banners.

    Australia’s largest publicly funded broadcasting service, the ABC is similarly under constant attack from politicians and vested interests on both sides of the fence – and it gets much more of the taxpayers’ moolah than its equivalent here. When the right’s in power, what is now laughingly called the left accuses it of anti-Labor bias; when the situation is reversed the right accuses it of bias against the Liberal Party. In fact what it does is report what has happened, not what the government and/or opposition wants us to think has happened. Every year, it is threatened with bigger and bigger cuts to its budget allocation and every year it must struggle harder to achieve what its charter mandates it must. As an executive of Canada’s equivalent once said: “Governments hate feeding the hand that bites them”.

    I am relieved to learn that the publicity has done Williams’ career at Faux News no harm whatsoever – even enhanced it, fattening his purse in the process. Of course the timing was probably just a coincidence, knowing as we do the high ethical standards upheld by the doyens of that worthy institution.

  • chinatl

    Steve Krodman (and many others):

    None of the terrorist incidents you mention--not a single one--involved men in so-called Muslim garb. The three incidents you mention were carried out by men of three different races, all wearing entirely familiar western clothes. The same is true of nearly all the terrorist incidents in the US and Great Britain since the beginning of the War on Terror . So if you’re going to get nervous on a plane and start judging people by their looks, your anxiety is better placed on men of any race wearing a button-down shirt and pants with shoes and underwear. Good luck with that; you’re going to need some Valium. Seemingly, if he’s wearing a thobe, you can breathe a sigh of relief.

Reading: Politics

Click here for more stories.
Point to view excerpt.
Click headline to view story.

  • Like the Dew?

    We are non-commercial, all volunteer and supported by our readers. Please help sustain the Dew by making a donation.