« | Home | »

Politics

The right to shut down Amtrak

by Piney Woods Pete | 4, Add your Comment | Sep 16, 2009

The U.S. Senate has agreed that Amtrak must allow guns to be carried in checked baggage.

It might be a Second Amendment thing but it’s mostly an unfunded mandate.

Amtrak banned firearms from its trains in the aftermath of the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. Senator Roger Wicker of Mississippi, the sponsor of the Amtrak gun language added to the transportation and housing appropriations measure currently before Congress, argued that all domestic airlines permit firearms in checked luggage and Amtrak should do the same.

The guns on the rails amendment received bipartisan support, but isn’t included in the House version so there is still time to take sides.

Amtrak, cash strapped and short on both political and popular support, is protesting that setting up a gun check-in as required will be prohibitively expensive and time-consuming.

On the Senate floor this week Wicker said Amtrak was preventing free exerccise of the Second Amendment by denying the right to carry firearms in locked, hard-side cases in checked baggage.

The more pure Second Amendment claim would be that passengers should be allowed to fire at railroad crossing signs from moving trains. Otherwise, what’s a free state all about?

printer friendly


Note: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for the agreed-upon rules of civility. Comments do not reflect the views of LikeTheDew.com. Comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click here to report a violation.

4 Responses to “The right to shut down Amtrak”

  1. Boyd Lewis Boyd Lewis says:
    September 20, 2009 at 10:48 pm

    My Second Amendment sensibilities are indeed offended by Amtrak segregating firearms and even crew-served weaponry to checked baggage in the car back behind the dining car. Like some of our enlightened states, I demand open carrying of firearms. Why, the Second Amendment guaranteeing flintlocks for a regulated citizen militia to defend us from marauding British or Canadian (shudder) soldiers on our soil in no way forbids my carrying aboard a vintage Schmeisser MP43 anywhere in public, so I may plink Lyndon Larouche supporters with their Obama=Hitler posters with gay abandon. You can get my machinenpistolen when you pry it from my cold, dead, chaffed, splintered-fingernailed, calloused hands. Feh!

    Reply
  2. C Smith says:
    September 21, 2009 at 10:38 am

    Do you think if our Presidents, Senate, Congress, and Supreme Court had kept our Constitution up to date over the last 200 years instead of trying to change it all at once might have averted todays confrontations.

    Reply
  3. C Smith says:
    September 21, 2009 at 10:51 am

    Punctuation should have been ? just in case the grammar police are out.

    Reply
  4. Brenden Brenden says:
    September 21, 2009 at 12:59 pm

    Why not stop funding this ridiculous anti-competitive failed enterprise and end the debate. Oh, that’s right: because everyone’s a racist. I always forget about that…

    Reply

Leave a Comment

What is CAPTCHA and why do I have to enter it to post a comment?

Quick answer: Look at the picture (below) that contains letters. Type those letters in the CAPTCHA Code box.

Longer explanation: Our comment system now requires a CAPTCHA test (an acronym for "Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart" for all comments (unless you have registered and are logged-in). CAPTCHA is an image of letters that is dynamically generated (click the speaker icon to hear it or the arrows to load another test that may be easier to read). The letters, because they're part of an image and not text (e.g. text that you could cut and paste), are difficult for a spambot or other computer program to read. Yet, a person has little trouble reading the letters in a captcha image and then typing them into the form. Using a captcha test on our website is a great way to ensure, for instance, that a person and not a spambot is filling out a web form (we used to get 100 or so spam comments every day which our volunteers had to wade through). Also, a captcha can make it difficult for a person to continuously resubmit form information and overwhelm our comment function. If you hate CAPTCHA, just register on LikeTheDew.com and login (registration is on the bottom left of our home page) and you won't be stopped by CAPTCHA.

You can add images to your comment by clicking here.

Related Posts

Piney Woods Pete
Piney Woods Pete
About the author Piney Woods Pete: Hard-charging salesman by day, Piney Woods Pete stays up late into the foggy night to render words.

Last 5 posts by Piney Woods Pete