Politics
Americans are better than that
We Americans love to pat ourselves on the back about the smooth transition of government following elections and lauding it, rightly, as evidence of the strength of democracy in action. Presidential campaigns could be hard fought, but when the dust settled and votes were counted, we as Americans, because we respected the office, respected the man who was president. It is a basic lesson most of us have taught our children — you don’t have to agree with someone, but you respect them as an individual and a fellow human being.

Republican Representative Joe Wilson of South Carolina shouts as President Barack Obama addresses a joint session of Congress on Sept. 9, 2009
I have watched in appalled wonder recently as adults behaved badly in public meetings on health care and wondered what kind of example they felt they were setting for their children about how to resolve conflicts. Until this summer, I thought such behavior was reserved for sports arenas at best or street mobs at worst.
Recently, I’ve been thinking about how the United States must appear to the rest of the world. Only nine months ago, we were being admired around the world for the progressive leadership we showed in electing the first African-American president. How do we look now I wonder? What do Jews around the world and others who felt the real life oppression and deadly cruelty of the Nazi government, think when people here call the president Hitler because they disagree with him politically? What do Afghans think as they await the recount of their recent election as Americans — both private citizens and elected representatives — unhappy with their own election’s results, turn to lies, distortion and disruption, at every turn.
Last night’s indecorous display by Rep. Joe Wilson from South Carolina, reached new lows. I was embarrassed for Wilson and my country. We are better than that.
Image credit: Chip Somodevilla / Getty Images / Time
-
I thought we’d reached an epic low when Bush2 was elected the second time. But recent developments…are disturbing. I don’t know where to place my shock. I’ll leave it here for a time, Jennifer, if you don’t mind.
-
Will we continue to let these people not only thwart the legislative process but also diminish our part in that process? If we are to be taken seriously, as Southerners, we must take a stand. Although this is a wonderful place to start, change must to take place outside of a website where we all hover together.
“On this site, we explore some of the reasons for those differences. We single out for praise the best aspects of our region’s culture and politics, and we quite openly advocate changing our region’s worst attributes.”The time has come.
-
Bang on commetary, Jennifer, on a disturbing trend. Fortunately, our president has demonstrated time and again that he is not of that ilk, and, so far, the majority of the American public has shown that they approve of his path. Wilson needs to take a look at the last conservative office holders who practiced those tactics and their career trajectories. Newt who?
-
Here’s what I don’t understand. Why are we all so outraged about this outburst, when the right has been doing pretty much the same thing in other ways? Town hall meetings, editorials, on the radio. It’s NOT okay to call the president a liar in the dignified Capitol building, but we can question everything he does, right down to the validity of his birth certificate, and that’s just peachy keen? The right wing supposedly represents personal responsibility, but they opposed letting a Demcorat preach those same virtues to our children? My right-wing friends tend to descend into schoolyard taunts when I try to engage them in serious discussion about stuff. So many of them never read a newspaper and seem to rely on right-wing radio for most of their information. Facts seem to have little place in their world view.
I desperately want to see that there is some hope for civil discussion and compromise, but I cannot find the evidence out there. -
South Carolina must have some diseased water under the PeeDee. From its delegate’s instance to preserve slavery in the Declaration of Independence in 1776 to that rabid morons John C. Calhoun and E. Mendel Rivers and Knegrow-schtupping Strom Thurmond to its governor confusing a sex trip to an Argentine foozy with hiking the Appalachian Trail to shouting out “liar” to the President, South Ka-Ka-La-LAKA has humiliated its wonderful people and glorious heritage (not to mention its magical city Charleston)d once too often. F**k Joe Wilson and his ilk. You racist sumbitches have once again fired upon Fort Sumpter. Fix bayonets. ?Citadel boys, CHARGE!
-
“Republican, racist!”
“Republican, racist!”I won’t defends Wilson’s actions because it gives morons whose entire political ideology relies upon fomenting racial grudges an excuse to further Balkanize our society into racial voting blocks. And, I guess, Wilson just shouldn’t have yelled out just because that’s not how we conduct our political business. But to Wilson’s point for which he should have chosen another venue…
Obama lies. His whole promise-long, detail-short public option speech that says insurance companies can cover more policy holders by extending benefits and capping premiums is certainly a lie and or quite stupid. He lied about the existence of opposition policy alternatives. He lied about how this program can be funded and its savings, according to the Congressional Budget Office. And he lies when he says if you like your health insurance, you can keep it.
I sort of secretly hope that you all get what you wish for so you can see for yourselves how destructive it will be. Apparently that’s the only way people — obviously not the people posting here — will learn. How businesses will shutter and more capital will flee from the U.S. How the dollar will crash and inflation will soar. How prices for food, gas and utilities will rocket. How unemployment will leap from 13 to 26 percent. Just another opportunity to remind you that this is what your blithering race-baiting nonsense is supporting.
-
So, yes, Obama lied. He lied because his measure does nothing to address the problem of illegal immigration healthcare. Illegals call 911 because they know hospitals will not deny them care if a hospital admits them from an ambulance. Consequently, our medical infrastructure bears the additional cost of indigent illegals obtaining the most expensive trauma care for routine medical problems. We the people pay more and wait longer for our justifiable emergency procedures.
I won’t blame Barry for this problem but I will say Joe Wilson accurately points out Obama’s measures that proport to solve this problem are intentionally reported to be false, that is, a pack of lies.
The solution, of course, is to admit the illegals to hospitals, treat them until they are stable — then detain them, deport them and seize all recoverable assets to pay for their care. Of course, neither party will support this measure because it makes too much sense.
-
Brendan: Deep in the night, when there is no one around and the stereo is quiet, all televisions and computers are off and there is no book or magazine in your hands, do you really believe in your heart that the quest for racial equality in health care will cause businesses to shutter, capital to flee from the United States, the dollar to crash, inflation to soar, prices for food, gas and utilities to rocket and for unemployment to jump to 26 percent?
Forget all this give-and-take on The Dew. Just level with me: Honest to Jesus God, do you really believe that? -
“the quest for racial equality in health care”
Please elaborate
-
Brendan: See Race, Health Care and the Southern Strategy posted on August 20.
-
Cliff,
You and your comrades keep pounding away on the theory that healthcare “reform” opposition is just a cracker conspiracy to keep minorities down. I think you will find that line of argumentation is inherently limiting. I don’t think a majority of folks want to get on that bus because they don’t want to involve themselves in a racial grudge match that only divides us further.
How come nobody on this site ever wants to talk about how to actually pay for any of the programs for which you advocate? Isn’t that the essence of responsible gov’t?
-
Although almost none of the above relates to the original editorial by Jennifer Hill, I will answer Brenden, that nobody talks about how to actually pay for the healthcare plan (which will help people), just the way nobody talked about how to pay for the Iraq war. How are we paying for that, by the way?
A few ways to help pay for the healthcare plan (others can pile on as ideas occur): end Medicare fraud (I believe that is currently underway with more gusto than any past administration attempted), end the War on Drugs (tons of money in that pile) since it hasn’t actually ended drug use and probably just makes it worse.
More people will have access to healthcare insurance and will be paying premiums, which pays for the healthcare plan. Also, it wouldn’t hurt my feelings if private insurance companies endured lower profit margins by making access to their products available to more people (people who will be paying premiums), a portion of those who are considered a potential drag to the bottom line.
Jeesh. I’d love to edit and re-edit, but I haven’t even had my morning tea. Out of the way, gotta run.
-
I really don’t understand this petulant line of argumentation. Because Bush wasted X dollars on Y failed gov’t initiative, Obama has the right to match that failed expenditure and regulation on another failed program. Too many of you here think I come to this site to defend George W. Bush’s legislative record. I do not. He did a lot of bad stuff. I think the time is right to roll up the carpets in Afghanistan and Iraq if the political leadership is not willing to suffer the bad publicity that it will take for the job to be done correctly; if you want to win the war sometimes you must bomb the village. End the war on drugs, OK by me. Let’s pass those free trade deals to Columbia while we’re at it.
But in light of all the mismanagement you referenced, why do you think now is the time for an expensive and intrusive gov’t misadventure into our bodies? What about the history of gov’t welfare programs leads you to the conclusion that this will costlessly benefit the entire country? What about Obama’s college lecturer and community organizer past leads you to believe he has any expertise in healthcare? What about the Democrat plundering Congressional leadership leads you to believe they could be honest brokers of anything? What is their record on exposing and preventing waste, fraud and abuse? Your utter faith in the honest of Democrat leadership seems to me based entirely on the partisan label — the GOP is no better, most likely. This strikes me as painfully naive. I’m not here crying partisan foul play. I just don’t want the federal gov’t under any administration controlling the healthcare system in this country.
You’re absolutely wrong about this: “Also, it wouldn’t hurt my feelings if private insurance companies endured lower profit margins by making access to their products available to more people (people who will be paying premiums), a portion of those who are considered a potential drag to the bottom line.” The gov’t allows these monopolies to exist by preventing interstate competition. If you take away their monopolist profit, then they will simply go out of business and force all their policy holders onto the public system.
That’s where you all are so far off on the opposition movement in this country. It’s about Constitutional limits, promoting free enterprise and the private relationship between patients and doctors. It’s not an entirely partisan movement. It’s about fundemental principles of right and wrong.
Leave a Comment
Related Posts
- Rude, crude and socially unacceptable may be what we need
- Politics as a spectator sport?
- The Right’s Outrageous Claims
- Who’s prevaricating now?
- An outsider’s view of the President, politics and the Holy Say
- American Xenophobia is Nothing New
- Southern to the bone, and scared witless
- Can You Hear?
- Obama wins Nobel
- Obama On The Cusp Of History…Again
Last 5 posts by Jennifer Hill
- Dodging Palin Misfires - February 10th, 2010
- Yo’ Jimmy, The Crease is Clean - July 21st, 2009
- Friendly community welcomes a 'Savage' - July 14th, 2009
- Postcard: Fresh from the garden - June 26th, 2009
- Postcard: After storm, time to garden - April 17th, 2009


21 Responses to “Americans are better than that”